NYC restaurants located within a 5 minute walk of City Hall Station | Ratings, Reviews & Maps

I love this place. My only complaint is sometimes, loud popular music is playing and I wish they would play folk, French, jazz, or anything unique really, that isn’t a repeat of every other typical American coffee shop. Ambience is everything. Also, the lights are a little bright so neurodivergent people can’t stay as long a they’d like. Oh, and when you get a little salad on the side of something it comes with no oil or vinegar, so it’s just dry greens. Staff is excellent. They make you feel like they want you there.
Natalie Baginski - 2 months ago

Le Pain Quotidien is a cozy, casual café and bakery that feels like a little European escape right in NYC. The focus here is on simple, wholesome food — think freshly baked organic bread, tartines (open-faced sandwiches), soups, salads, coffee, and pastries — all made with quality ingredients and lots of vegetarian/vegan options. I popped in for a late breakfast and loved the relaxed, communal vibe with long wooden tables and lots of natural light. My coffee and pastry were nice and comforting, and the tartine I ordered was fresh and flavorful without being too heavy. It’s a great spot for a chill brunch or midday coffee break. That said, service can be a bit slow during busy times, and it’s a bit pricier compared to some other cafés, with mixed feedback from other diners about consistency. Overall, if you’re in the mood for a healthy, laid-back café meal with European flair, Le Pain Quotidien is worth a stop.
Tctgb1 - 3 weeks ago

The staff were incredibly friendly and efficient, making me feel welcome right away. I ordered a matcha latte with almond milk and an avocado toast. The avocado was wonderfully fresh, though the bread was a bit on the stiff side. On the other hand, the croissants were fresh, flaky, and absolutely delicious. Overall, it was a great experience.
Golnaz J N - a year ago

Beautiful and cozy spot for breakfast or brunch in the city! Le Pain Quotidien has a warm, rustic atmosphere that feels both relaxing and stylish. The organic breads and pastries are fresh, flavorful, and perfectly baked. I especially loved the croissants and the avocado toast — simple but delicious. The service was friendly and efficient, and the space is very clean and comfortable for dining in. Great place to meet friends, work on a laptop, or enjoy a quiet meal. Prices match the quality and location. Definitely a place I will return to!
Kavita Panchal - 3 months ago

Read all Reviews

I try not to go off a restaurant based off a pickup order but the food is decent. Portioning for the price is a bit off but the hot honey sauce on the wings had a nice spice to it. If your heat sensitive, one or two fries will do the trick. Service was excellent and I really want to try their desserts out next time I go. This is an establishment that would be good for a meeting, date, or after work wine down.
Darroll Morris - 4 months ago

Fantastic sports bar with great food and an awesome atmosphere! Mudville is the perfect place to relax after work or hang out with friends. The ribs were tender and full of flavor, and the wings were crispy and delicious. Huge selection of beers on tap and classic pub drinks. The space is clean, stylish, and comfortable with a rustic vibe. Staff were friendly, attentive, and fast even during busy hours. Prices are fair for the quality and location. Highly recommended if you’re in the area — I’ll definitely be back!
Kavita Panchal - 3 months ago

Read all Reviews

Got takeout for dinner comped by work. Not as fresh quality as Soho Sushi. The amount of soy sauce they gave (less than half a cup) was definitely not enough. The wasabi quality is also not good - weird vibrant green color. Won’t be getting this again - Sushi dinner set w/ miso soup: 6/10, I feel like the sushi quality wasn’t very fresh. One of the yellow tail nigiri pieces was a little bloody? California roll was standard. The miso soup is standard and good tho
Mei Deng - 2 months ago

I love the chicken terriyaki lunch special. The sushi is also incredible! Generous partition of food and friendly staff!
Sadie Goodman - 2 months ago

Not enough soy sauce in the container - not even enough for one roll. They also didn't provide a spoon for the miso soup. Ordered the 3-roll lunch special on GrubHub. Glad they followed the note to not add wasabi though. I would order again!
Tian Carling - 2 months ago

This is surprisingly affordable and fresh sushi. I should say we ordered vegan dishes for all eight of us, so I cannot comment on the sashimi or other sushi that there are other mixed reviews on. We enjoy the miso, avocado cucumber and sweet potato tempura rolls. The food was delivered quickly too! If you have a big family to feed and want to have sushi, this is a great option for vegans/vegetarians.
Mrs Senthil - a year ago

They are great for what they are. Service is quick and attentive. Perfectly cooked rice, veggies and chicken. They have lunch specials but Spacing gets a bit cramped during lunch hours.
Nernemsaa Golding - a year ago

Read all Reviews

Perfect meal on an icy day. I was lured in by the lunch special displayed on the outside and it even came with chai ! The chicken was nice and juicy and the vegetables very nicely spiced. Left a clean plate and it was a cozy environment on a blisteringly cold day.
Kate Mao - a month ago

Today was my first time here even though I have worked in the area for a while. The staff is so welcoming and friendly. The server made great suggestions and the food was delicious. What I liked best was the spicing of the food was perfect. I had The Feast, one chicken dish, one veggie and rice. I find Indian cooking is a real art. All the spices blended well so the rice, eggplant and chicken tikki created explosions of wonderful experiences in my mouth. The price is amazing! $13.75 for a tasty and extremely satisfying meal in this neighborhood is exceptional. Especially since we are in inflationary times. I was too full to have dessert. Their dessert menu looked so tempting. I will have to go back to try other dishes and leave enough room for dessert. Can’t wait to try their Moong Dal Halwa - sweet lentil pudding with nuts and ghee! Yummy! I highly recommend this place if you want reasonably priced, delicious food while feeling welcomed by the friendly staff.
Howard Edelbaum - 3 months ago

Tikka masala food was great however, the place doesn't have restrooms and the pickles were hard to eat
Erhancan Kotar - a month ago

The feast portion is perfect for a student, it’s vegetables, a meat, and a bunch of delicious white rice for 13.75. The food was absolutely delicious and the staff were so friendly and helpful.
Liz Knott - 4 months ago

Delicious the food is fast and affordable! You can get a meal for $13! Got the Chicken Tika Masala eggplant and rice. Garlic naan is delicious. Also tried the Papri chat and malai kofta very flavorful! The workers are very nice
Sage Lau - 4 months ago

Read all Reviews

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Tre Sorelle is an absolute gem. From the moment you walk in, the service is warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. The pizza is outstanding — perfectly crisp crust, high-quality ingredients, and balanced flavors in every bite. But the real standout? The vodka sauce. It’s hands down one of the best I’ve ever had rich, creamy, and packed with flavor without being too heavy. You can taste the care in every dish. If you’re looking for incredible pizza and top-tier service, Tre Sorelle delivers every single time. Highly recommend.
Jose B - a month ago

Wow. ! I just had the veal Marsala for lunch So good and tasty. Excellent service and the restaurant is so nice and cozy inside. I highly recommend if you want a great meal
Greg Sura - 4 months ago

This place is just phenomenal. Ive had the spaghetti and meatballs, and their pizza with vodka sauce (I added pepperoni and shrooms). Owner is a very nice guy. The pizza is somewhere between NYC and Neapolitan, and it really works. The pepperoni is cupped, and the mushrooms thin sliced white crimini. They do have an enormous menu, so unless the guy is a wizard some items are probably bad, but he also might be a wizard.
Nathan Baum - 4 months ago

Intimate, delicious and great service. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a quiet relaxing evening with a great slice of pizza.
Giovany Aguado - 3 months ago

Bread basket was hot and fresh! Everything was a hit.
James C - a month ago

Read all Reviews

Great hole in the wall pizzeria. The pizza was delicious. It has a decent sized dining room but a tiny bathroom-it’s NYC!
Beautiful, Blessed & Highly Favored - a month ago

Nice authentic NY style pizza 🍕 in the middle of Manhattan! Atmosphere is great, but locale is a bit small, which is understandable given the location 😉.
Philippe Veltsos - 3 months ago

New Yorker here born & raised. Queens to be exact. This spot is hands down my favorite pizza right now. I honestly haven’t had a slice this good since I was a little girl. I only wish my Papa was still here to be able to enjoy a slice from here w/ me. Nonetheless, my loved ones are all getting a slice from here. The dough the sauce the fast service classic & delicious NYC pizza. I suggest this spot for a delicious slice of pizza (OR PIES🙃🤤😍) to anyone who loves good food…or snack. I do not judge! Get here early as possible cause it does get real busy. Like line out the door busy. If you got the time it’s def worth the wait. Enjoy! & thank you. Little Italy pizza!! Please don’t ever change. Sincerely, A hardworking New Yorker 🩵
Stephanie Taylor - 9 months ago

Crowded pizza joint. BUT the staff was very enthusiastic and up beat. I stopped here expecting your run of the mill NYC pizza place. The food far exceeded my expectation and I will be sure to add this place to my must stops in NYC. The pepperoni with FRESH CUT jalapeños was fantastic!
Daniel Shook - a month ago

It was good pizza. Had good experience. The service was fast even though they were super busy.
binal patel - 7 months ago

Read all Reviews

The satisfaction I got from eating here… a solid 10/10. Everything was on point. The staff was genuinely helpful, and the menu had so many options I had to take a moment and regroup before ordering. The garlic bread? Soft, flavorful, and honestly way better than it has any right to be. And the toppings? Pick whatever you want — the dough carries the whole team. When the base is this good, it’s basically impossible to make a bad choice. I’ll definitely be back. This place knows what it’s doing.
Leilani M - 4 months ago

Saw this on Here Be Bar on YouTube. We were in the area, so we went to check it out. Food was blah. Crust was flavorless. Wasn't very clean. Owner was kinda rude. There are much nicer places for pizza in the city.
BlueBox Media - a year ago

Pizza was good, cheesy and stringy. I had the regular cheese pizza which was thinly sliced and great size. I visited right before lunch time during the week so it wasnt busy. There were lots of seating areas and clean enough.
Hazel Valentine - 6 months ago

Amazing pizza spot for anyone who likes pizza. Amazing selection, and all of them are good, you can’t go wrong. The options, price and people are amazing here. I had 2 slices and this pizza spot looks low key, but the taste is high key. Would recommend this place to anyone coming near Times Square a must go for pizza lots of veggie options too. 5/5
Araash Chothia - 3 years ago

Awesome! Great prices and delicious pizza. They had Coke Zero and a lot of other diet options. I had the meat lovers and the Bacon chicken pizza so so good! Fast and friendly staff.
Jennifer Winthurst - 3 years ago

Read all Reviews

One of the best indian spots in the city. Located in a great area and the inside is really well done. The owner made sure to pay attention to the small details of the place and the servers were very, very quick. I've been to a lot of service restaurants but nothing beats the speed of the service they had. They always asked if everything was alright. And alright as an answer would be a major understatement. The food was to die for and is reasonably priced considering the area and size of the place inside. Will recommend to anyone to come here and try the food P.S: A reservation is required to eat here but it's really worth it. We got a reservation the same day
Sawan Singh - 3 months ago

Very nice experience and service by Monir and Prashad. I got the Dal Tadka (lentils) and it was excellent. I had a special request to not use oil to prepare my dinner but butter instead, and to be easy on the salt and Prashad happily assured me. Very nice ambiance. My parents said their food was excellent as well.
Kyle Bhiro - 4 months ago

Benares Tribeca is a great choice if you’re craving authentic Indian flavors with a modern twist in a cozy yet stylish setting. The menu has a nice mix of classics — think fragrant biryani, rich butter chicken, crisp samosas, and flavorful tandoori chicken — and the naan and sauces are perfect for soaking up every last bite. I found the service friendly and attentive, and the vibe feels upscale without being pretentious — great for a date night or chill dinner with friends. The lunch deals are a nice bonus if you’re stopping by midday. If you’re new to Indian cuisine or want a well-rounded meal with bold, balanced spices, this spot delivered for me.
Tctgb1 - a month ago

While we were looking for an Indian restaurant around SoHo, Gemini recommended Benares and we never regretted it! It was my mom’s and sister’s first time trying Indian food, and they absolutely loved the experience, thanks in large part to our wonderful server, Mogambo. He was incredibly helpful with his recommendations. We ordered samosas, butter chicken, chicken vindaloo, and chicken kali mirch (which was just as excellent as Mogambo promised). We finished with rasmalai, which was delightful. Fantastic food and outstanding service, highly recommended!
Kerem Zaman - 2 months ago

Read all Reviews

Went here to try the mama's meatball sandwich. It was good, but the bread isn't baked on premises and just can't compare to many other competing sandwich shops. There is a good selection of soups, I tried the chili and it was delicious, better than the sandwich. Sadly, the employees here not only look like they don't want to be there, but they looked like they didn't want me to be there either. So I'll never be back.
Christopher Z - 7 months ago

😆Ohh Boy👏🏾, POTBELLY made my Day, it has A nice Menu, love the chicken Popeye soup & chili soup, Outstanding👏🏾🏆, there’s no place like Potbelly, Everything is so freshly made, in front of your eyes. I love the milkshakes too😋, If you ever in the City& feeling hungry, Head over to Pot Belly😆🤘🏾!!
Phillip Andre - a year ago

Amazing best sandwiches and soup in the city their wraps are to die for. Try their wrench sandwich with lettuce tomatos and onions and mayo but you can add what ever you want still delicious 😋
yiraldy lopez - 3 months ago

Read all Reviews