Best NYC restaurants located within a 5 minute walk of Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Station | Ratings, Reviews & Maps

The following New York City restaurants are all conveniently located within a 5 minute walk of the Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Subway Station. They are sorted according to their overall rating on Yelp. When you are looking for a great place to eat near Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Station in NYC, any of the following restaurants should prove to be a good choice.

Totonno's

Yelp Rating:
4 out of 5 4 Star Rating
Based on 809 Reviews.

Totonno's
Totonno's map

Price: $$

Category: Pizza

Address:
1524 Neptune Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 372-8606

5 Star Rating Great restaurant and they gave back to the community during COVID-19 what more can you ask for Read More

B H. Aug-10-2020

5 Star Rating Totonno's you are totally fantastic, I had a wonderful experience here today. I only had high expectations only because I've heard so much about Totonno's.... Read More

Joseph D. Jun-02-2021

3 Star Rating THEY ARE CLOSED! Traveled 2 hours to get here on a Saturday at 4pm on 6/5/21 and they are apparently permanently closed, even though it does not say so... Read More

Dan L. Jun-05-2021

ChowTime

Yelp Rating:
4.5 out of 5 4.5 Star Rating
Based on 48 Reviews.

ChowTime
ChowTime map

Price: $

Category: Vietnamese Bubble Tea Chinese

Address:
1418 Mermaid Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (347) 713-1560

5 Star Rating Every time I'm. It sure what to eat anymore I eat T chow time! Why? Because it's my go-to spot for comfort. I love this place. Great food! Read More

Carmen R. Jan-24-2021

4 Star Rating Get the banh mi here - we got the Classic Vietnamese (or something like that), and oh man, was it good with nicely seasoned ground beef, pate, ham, etc.... Read More

Austin K. May-06-2021

5 Star Rating My favorite joint! Chicken fried dumplings and crab raccoon is a must! Everything else is also so so good!!!! Trust me! Read More

Carmen B. Nov-01-2020

Doña Zita Mexican Restaurant

Yelp Rating:
4 out of 5 4 Star Rating
Based on 74 Reviews.

Doña Zita Mexican Restaurant
Doña Zita Mexican Restaurant map

Price: $

Category: Mexican

Address:
1221 Bowery St
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (347) 492-6160

5 Star Rating I've ordered on location and had it delivered though a delivery service. Delicious! $8 gorditas. They're huge. Tried the chorizo ones and the carnitas. Both... Read More

Isaac D. Jun-15-2020

5 Star Rating I ordered the potato flautas, a chicken taco and a fried pork taco. This was the best Mexican food I have had since coming to NYC! I've been here working... Read More

Sheena H. Jun-30-2020

5 Star Rating Excellent tacos for $4. They have 2 lines, one for just tacos in the entrance and the other line to order everything else. They have HUGE sandwiches:... Read More

Carl T. Aug-18-2019

On The Run Pizza

Yelp Rating:
4.5 out of 5 4.5 Star Rating
Based on 22 Reviews.

On The Run Pizza
On The Run Pizza map

Price: $

Category: Pizza

Address:
1627 Mermaid Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 946-6677

5 Star Rating On The Run Pizza you are absolutely fantastic, I had a spectacular experience here today. The vibe is great. Everything I've tried here was flavorful.... Read More

Crystle S. May-23-2021

5 Star Rating If you've got a prodigious quantity of delicious Coney Island Beer (located at Coney Island Brewery a couple blocks away), and five large On The Run pies,... Read More

Peter D. May-29-2018

5 Star Rating Make sure you type in address for they have 2 locations. Customer service was great, place seemed clean, Pizza was hot and ready, even with me being a block... Read More

Tasz W. Feb-26-2020

Nathan's Famous

Yelp Rating:
3.5 out of 5 3.5 Star Rating
Based on 1231 Reviews.

Nathan's Famous
Nathan's Famous map

Price: $

Category: Hot Dogs Seafood Burgers

Address:
1310 Surf Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 946-2202

4 Star Rating It took nine years for this Bay Area California girl to make it to Coney Island after being an NYC resident for more than half that time, meeting my... Read More

Steph Q. Apr-25-2021

4 Star Rating They're doing a Throwback Thursdays 5 cents hot dog promotion with the purchase of a full sized item. I ordered a large bacon cheese fry and a hot dog. The... Read More

Michelle L. Apr-29-2021

4 Star Rating My friend and I came for a Saturday afternoon beach day at Coney Island. I've only ever had Nathan's in Manhattan from their little carts so it was pretty... Read More

Deborah W. Sep-13-2020

Gargiulo's

Yelp Rating:
3.5 out of 5 3.5 Star Rating
Based on 246 Reviews.

Gargiulo's
Gargiulo's map

Price: $$

Category: Italian Venues & Event Spaces Seafood

Address:
2911 W 15th St
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 266-4891

5 Star Rating They catered our wedding during COVID and were amazing. Everyone was raving about the wedding food, which you just don't hear that often. The calamari... Read More

Ben C. Jun-01-2021

5 Star Rating What a fantastic evening we had! Outdoor seating was plentiful and there was more than enough social distancing space between tables. The servers... Read More

C S. Aug-29-2020

5 Star Rating Enjoyed a multi-course (forgot how many) meal at Gargiulo's in connection w/ the HeartShare Annual Gala (virtual this year). Got there late and asked... Read More

Patrick F. Apr-16-2021

Pizza On the Run

Yelp Rating:
4 out of 5 4 Star Rating
Based on 29 Reviews.

Pizza On the Run
Pizza On the Run map

Price: $

Category: Pizza

Address:
2932 Stillwell Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 946-6677

5 Star Rating On The Run Pizza you are absolutely fantastic, I had a spectacular experience here today. The vibe is great. Everything I've tried here was flavorful.... Read More

Crystle S. May-23-2021

5 Star Rating If you've got a prodigious quantity of delicious Coney Island Beer (located at Coney Island Brewery a couple blocks away), and five large On The Run pies,... Read More

Peter D. May-29-2018

5 Star Rating Make sure you type in address for they have 2 locations. Customer service was great, place seemed clean, Pizza was hot and ready, even with me being a block... Read More

Tasz W. Feb-26-2020

Surf City Pizzeria

Yelp Rating:
3.5 out of 5 3.5 Star Rating
Based on 48 Reviews.

Surf City Pizzeria
Surf City Pizzeria map

Price: $

Category: Pizza Wraps Italian

Address:
837 Surf Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 676-4460

4 Star Rating Desperate for a place to eat after traveling all day and ending up at Coney Island and this place was the only thing open as the rest of the island was... Read More

Faye T. May-05-2020

3 Star Rating Food here is just okay. It is very easy to get to as it is just off the West 8th St/New York Aquarium station on the F/Q lines. You could also walk the... Read More

Matthew S. Dec-16-2020

3 Star Rating Visited the aquarium and decided on pizza on our way out. Coney Island is literally a ghost town in January so we literally had the restaurant to ourselves.... Read More

Tonya B. Feb-08-2020

Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest

Yelp Rating:
3.5 out of 5 3.5 Star Rating
Based on 34 Reviews.

Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest
Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest map

Category: Hot Dogs

Address:
1310 Surf Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 946-2202

5 Star Rating What could possibly be more fun than watching grown men stuffing their faces with as many hotdogs as possible in 10 minutes? Believe it or not, this crazy... Read More

Al M. Jul-04-2020

1 Star Rating After seeing the news that Nathan's have vegan hotdogs, myself and my Friends drove specifically for that and to our surprise! NO VEGAN HOTDOGS! This is... Read More

Felicia L. May-16-2021

5 Star Rating Love the 4th of July!!! To get to watch these professional eaters gourge on hot dogs is a tradition at my house!!! I mean Joey Chestnut he's the man. The... Read More

Paige C. Jul-04-2020

Margarita Island

Yelp Rating:
3.5 out of 5 3.5 Star Rating
Based on 38 Reviews.

Margarita Island
Margarita Island map

Price: $$

Category: Bars American (Traditional)

Address:
1105 Bowery St
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (917) 723-3232

5 Star Rating Good place to get a solid draft beer and margarita! Plenty of outdoor seating and nice staff! Read More

cherry c. Sep-06-2020

4 Star Rating I was reluctant to try this place out. During the week happy hours are 11-1 and 4-6. The margaritas are 2 for 1 so I had the paasion fruit margarita and a... Read More

Shirrell H. Jun-10-2019

3 Star Rating I came in the fall, after the off-season had begun and the rides close down at 6pm and most of the boardwalk is shuttered and deserted. I had no idea Coney... Read More

Lucy M. Dec-15-2019

New York City Culinary Tours

Tour depiction

Greenwich Village Italian Heritage Food Tour

Rating 4.5 Star Rating

From: $81.44 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

This is a fun-filled interactive walking tour of Greenwich Village's Italian neighborhood. See St. Anthony's Church, Raffetto's Pasta Store and then stroll MacDougal Street's Caffe Reggio. This 2-hour tour is led by a local, licensed NYC tour guide with Italian family roots in the neighborhood for over 125 years. Your food tour guide gives you an insider's perspective into local history with music, serenades and family tales.   Greg Walks NYC employees, are released/discharged, from and against any/all liability from participation in Greg Walks NYC Tours, and is legally binding on participant, heirs, successors assigns and legal reps. Tour participants assume all travel risks. Gregory Marro and Greg Walks NYC are released from all/any liabilities and penalties to the legal maximum permitted by law. Tourists MUST inform tour guide of any/all food allergies. Greg Walks NYC tour pics/videos may be used on social media.Samples and sights subject to change.

Book Now

Tour depiction

NYC Chelsea and West Village Dessert Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $75.44 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Get off the beaten path in Chelsea and the West Village while tastings some of the best desserts and sweets in the area. You'll learn about the city’s culinary past, all while trying fresh hot doughnuts, half pound cookies, artisan chocolates from the city's oldest chocolate house, create a mini cupcake, try unique ice cream flavors in the summer months or enjoy a toasty hot chocolate in the winter, with a total of 6 tastings altogether. Mosey through the quaint Chelsea neighborhood, into Chelsea Market, down the High Line, and into the Meatpacking District and end your culinary adventure in the West Village.

Book Now

Tour depiction

Greenwich Village Literary Pub Crawl

Rating 4.5 Star Rating

From: $45.29 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

A fascinating tour of the historic pubs and haunts of the the greatest literary minds of the United States, in one of the most influential and progressive neighborhoods in the world.

Book Now

Tour depiction

Chinatown and Little Italy Food Fest

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $99.38 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Explore the tastes and history of two ethnic NYC neighborhoods, Chinatown and Little Italy. Animated and friendly guides allow their guests to learn these neighborhoods through fascinating historical stories and culinary delights. The delicious food tastings range from homemade mozzarella to a sit-down authentic Chinese meal experience. One leaves this tour fully satisfied, along with a new found confidence in navigating the neighborhoods with a provided recommendation list in hand. This tour is a must if you're a local or visitor looking to get off-the-beaten path and taste amazing foods.

Book Now

Tour depiction

NYC West Village Pub Crawl

Rating 4 Star Rating

From: $25.88 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Experience the best of New York City’s wildly famous Greenwich Village in one night. Visit 4 of the Village’s hottest drinking establishments, featuring beer pong, karaoke, live bands, and DJ’s & dancing. You will receive free shots and admission fees at all locations.

Book Now

Tour depiction

New York City Secrets of Grand Central Terminal Tour

Rating 4 Star Rating

From: $45.29 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Did you know there is a hidden tennis court inside Grand Central? Or that the ceiling is backwards? Discover many more secrets on this tour and learn about the surprising history of this New York City icon! This tour is led by a native New Yorker who is a licensed New York City Tour guide.

Book Now

Get a New York City Explorer Pass - the most flexible NYC attraction pass available

No rushing. Valid for a full 30 days after you visit your first attraction.
Convenient. One pass for multiple attractions.
Flexible. Available for 3, 4, 5, 7, or 10 attractions. Choose from 78 top attractions as you go.
Even More Flexible. Build your own custom pass.


Visiting New York City?
Here's why we use Booking.com for our hotel bookings.
Best Selection
Daily Deals
Price Matching
Pay at the Hotel
24/7 Support
Share on Pinterest
Share on Pinterest
Help us grow! Please Share
Thanks for Visiting!