Best NYC restaurants located within a 5 minute walk of Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Station | Ratings, Reviews & Maps

The following New York City restaurants are all conveniently located within a 5 minute walk of the Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Subway Station. They are sorted according to their overall rating on Google Reviews and we display the most recent reviews for each restaurant. When you are looking for a great place to eat near Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Station in NYC, any of the following restaurants should prove to be a good choice.

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard    Overall Rating 4.5 out of 5Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Star Rating

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard restaurant
Photo Credit: Cindy M
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard map

Price Level: $$$$

Address: 1327 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 266-7482

Official Website: Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Reviews

5 Star Rating A rare treat, frozen custard is, abd this is the best I can remember since my childhood 60 years ago! Far better than the only other brand in New York City.

Anders R. Sterner - 1 month ago

5 Star Rating An absolute must have if you're anywhere near. The softest yet most flavorful ice that you can get on this side of Brooklyn. Hands down, worth the wait in line. I highly recommend the more fruity flavors as compared to the candy flavors/ice cream flavors.

Mermit bleh - 10 months ago

4 Star Rating They have all flavors and the products they sell are high quality. They even are kosher

Steven Sigman - 3 months ago

4 Star Rating Line was long at 10 pm--but Friday night is a fun time to stand in line in colorful Coney Island! Yummy frozen custard and ices. A 'regular' size was PLENTY.

Jackie DeGroat - 7 months ago

Pizza On The Run    Overall Rating 4.4 out of 5Pizza On The Run Star Rating

Pizza On The Run restaurant
Photo Credit: Geoffrey Liu
Pizza On The Run map

Price Level: $$$$

Open Now

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Thursday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Friday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Saturday: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Address: 1627 Mermaid Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 946-6677

Reviews

4 Star Rating Pizza Good, Could Use More Cheese Though

Sean Miguel Baez - 11 days ago

5 Star Rating Great place to eat with affordable prices. Friendly staff.

John Ospina - 1 month ago

4 Star Rating Small, relatively clean...not much on decor...but the pizza is the best in Coney Island. (But there's not a lot of pizza places in that area, so it is what it is, Facts. I guess that's what matters.

Roots ! - 4 months ago

5 Star Rating This was very good pizza.😍😍😍

Kim Taehyung - 22 days ago

4 Star Rating Great pizza the best in coney Island

Tanisha B - 2 months ago

Gargiulo's    Overall Rating 4.3 out of 5Gargiulo's Star Rating

Gargiulo's restaurant
Photo Credit: ZAGAT
Gargiulo's map

Price Level: $$$$

Currently Closed

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: 12:00 – 10:30 PM
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 12:00 – 10:30 PM
  • Thursday: 12:00 – 10:30 PM
  • Friday: 12:00 – 11:30 PM
  • Saturday: 12:00 – 11:30 PM
  • Sunday: 12:00 – 9:30 PM

Address: 2911 W 15th St, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 266-4891

Official Website: Gargiulo's

Reviews

5 Star Rating Exceptional service. Food was delicious. Atmoshere was great. Thanks for an awesome experience. You could really feel the history of the building/restaurant, which added tho the feel!

Brent Prise - 8 days ago

3 Star Rating This location was rented for a gala; the place is beautiful, the staff were exceptional. My low rating is for the food. While most people just came to have a good time, many found the food to be lacking in flavor. Overall, the ideal place to host a formal event

VICTORIA BOUSQUET - 13 days ago

5 Star Rating Amazing from the second you walk in. Always leave with a smile and a full stomach. Feel like I'm eating with family around me. Everyone having a great time and not wanting to leave this place is my second home

EZRA HAZAN - 3 months ago

5 Star Rating This is the best Italian American restaurant in the US IMO. Its like walking in on the set of the Godfather restaurant scene.

The One and only Pinky Pinky - 6 days ago

5 Star Rating Great event space, my job did holiday parties here every year. The food is always good. Plus for them having their own parking lots.

Nina R. - 2 months ago

Grimaldi's    Overall Rating 4.2 out of 5Grimaldi's Star Rating

Grimaldi's restaurant
Photo Credit: Grimaldi's
Grimaldi's map

Price Level: $$$$

Open Now

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: 12:00 – 8:00 PM
  • Tuesday: 12:00 – 8:00 PM
  • Wednesday: 12:00 – 8:00 PM
  • Thursday: 12:00 – 8:00 PM
  • Friday: 12:00 – 8:00 PM
  • Saturday: 12:00 – 8:00 PM
  • Sunday: 12:00 – 8:00 PM

Address: 1215 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 676-2630

Official Website: Grimaldi's

Reviews

5 Star Rating DELICIOUS PLACE WITH VERY SWEET STAFF & AMAZING PIZZA... WE WERE ALL HAPPY ESPECIALLY OUR DAUGHTERS...

Yael Read - 1 month ago

3 Star Rating Wasn’t a fan. Thought it would be a little different than here at home, but honestly I think the one in Dallas is better.

Shannon Eyman - 21 days ago

3 Star Rating Finally got to go out without our kids. Decided to enjoy some Grimaldi pizza and the location off-season. Spent 2 hours listening to the smashing of air hockey game played by loud kids while daddy was drinking with his buddies Since ceilings are high and there is not much to dampen the sound of it the noise was too prevalent.Needless to say it was not an enjoyable, adult experience.

Linnea Larsson - 2 months ago

4 Star Rating If you want to experience pizza straight out the oven, come to Grimaldi’s you won’t regret it. The Pizza Is made with love with all the toppings to choose from. The crust is thin and easy to eat. The environment is a fun family setting with projected screens on each side of the walls. 💯 fantastic pizzeria that all must try. Enjoy

Pierre Cheron - 5 months ago

Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana    Overall Rating 4.2 out of 5Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana Star Rating

Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana restaurant
Photo Credit: ZAGAT
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana map

Price Level: $$$$

Currently Closed

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: Closed
  • Thursday: 12:00 – 7:30 PM
  • Friday: 12:00 – 7:30 PM
  • Saturday: 12:00 – 7:30 PM
  • Sunday: 12:00 – 7:30 PM

Address: 1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 372-8606

Official Website: Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana

Reviews

3 Star Rating Pizza was good, but not much better that most Neapolitan places. The fresh mozzarella made in the store is definitely nice. Service was borderline indifferent. It's nice that it's an old school place but servers sitting at customers tables ignoring the rest loses the charm pretty quick. Seems to always be a wait but that's a function of popularity, the guy making pizzas was cranking them out as fast as he could. Price is based on reputation more than what it really is.

chris lietz - 3 months ago

5 Star Rating It's the way pizza should be. A thin, crunchy crust. Tasty sauce (possibly a little sour which personally I liked) and fresh cheese. It's probably true that you can find better pizza, but none as authentic. Totonno's doesn't try too hard to be the best, they simply have been making great pizza this way for eons. I only ordered the cheese pizza which in my opinion is the only way to truly compare different pizzerias. If I like it, then I try the toppings. This place is so good, I'm afraid to ruin it with toppings.

D A - 2 months ago

5 Star Rating The best Napolitan pizza I ever had. It will be great if they accept credit or debit cards. The service was good, even that the operational hours said starting at noon and We wait to more than 20 minutes outside, after the noon.

Tony Millan - 2 months ago

4 Star Rating Would be 5 but I heard they're racist and rude. They were super pleasant to us and seated us (group of 7) comfortably on a six table with a chair at the end. All in all Amazing cheese and great taste. If you're critical you'd probably dislike the slightly charred crust and the toppings being too heavy and falling off sometimes. But this is definitely a must try but not worth more then a 45 minute drive so ehhhhhkeep that in mind.

Levi Hazan - 2 months ago

3 Star Rating An old school pizzeria that has been around for close to a century. The only item on the menu is pizza which only comes by the pie and is overpriced. There is usually a wait and customer service is lacking. (Come on, guys. If everyone is complaining about the service, fix it!) Good but not spectacular.

RRR - 2 months ago

Nathan's Famous - Coney Island    Overall Rating 4.2 out of 5Nathan's Famous - Coney Island Star Rating

Nathan's Famous - Coney Island restaurant
Photo Credit: Michael Bastien
Nathan's Famous - Coney Island map

Price Level: $$$$

Open Now

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Thursday: 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM
  • Friday: 10:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Saturday: 10:00 AM – 12:00 AM
  • Sunday: 10:00 AM – 11:00 PM

Address: 1310 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 333-2202

Official Website: Nathan's Famous - Coney Island

Reviews

5 Star Rating It's the worlds famous Nathan’s Hot Dog what's not to love. I like to keep it simple plain with mustard and some old fashioned lemonade. However you like your hot dog just try one and will know why it is so good. I had to throw in the picture of frog legs just because it looks good.

Neville Emmanuel - 10 days ago

4 Star Rating Does exactly what it says on the tin! Good honest food reasonably priced. Restaurant is clean and efficiently run. The clam chowders are surprisingly good. Give it a go, you can't go wrong really

john tynan - 1 month ago

4 Star Rating What can I say... Good old Nathans is still good old Nathans. it was very good it was very busy inside but lines moved quickly. it looks like it was reorganized. help was very good. food was very good but not cheap but we had coupons

Barry Michaels - 2 months ago

4 Star Rating You gotta go to Nathan's! I had an original and it was a good dog. Not the best ever, but now I can say I've had one. Probably only 500 or so behind Joey Chestnut. Also had lobster roll which was good. Bit overpriced, but that's expected.

Chris Pautler - 14 days ago

Margarita Island    Overall Rating 4.1 out of 5Margarita Island Star Rating

Margarita Island restaurant
Photo Credit: Maria G
Margarita Island map

Price Level: $$$$

Open Now

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM
  • Tuesday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM
  • Wednesday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM
  • Thursday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM
  • Friday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM
  • Saturday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM
  • Sunday: 12:00 PM – 2:00 AM

Address: 1105 Bowery St, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (917) 723-3232

Official Website: Margarita Island

Reviews

5 Star Rating I like the service and the food was great

GENERAL DV M.I.N.G - 2 days ago

5 Star Rating Very strong drinks, and such a great atmosphere! I always make sure to stop here when I go to Coney Island!

Danielle Bishop - 1 month ago

5 Star Rating Our bar tender was super sweet! We went during happy hour, and she warned us against getting a fishbowl since it was tiny and we were looking to share! Thanks for being great! Margaritas were delishious!

Ashley Marie - 6 months ago

5 Star Rating Want a good frozen drink, come on into Margarita Island. Served quickly and cold. Very reasonable for Coney Island. Enjoy!

Brenda Paris - 6 months ago

5 Star Rating Drinks were amazing. Really cool place.

Bettrina Oliver - 3 months ago

IHOP    Overall Rating 4 out of 5IHOP Star Rating

IHOP restaurant
Photo Credit: Seth Hoyt
IHOP map

Price Level: $$$$

Open Now

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Thursday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Friday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Saturday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM
  • Sunday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Address: 1019 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 676-7220

Official Website: IHOP

Reviews

5 Star Rating Second time going! The hostesses are great and on a busy day, they manage to stay on top of everything. Food tastes amazing, despite the hashbrowns not being my favorite style.

Emily Edmeade - 4 days ago

5 Star Rating For a food chain, I really liked the place. A typical diner with simple pancakes and more. In addition, the service was great as well. Will be coming back.

Danil Ermolin - 2 months ago

4 Star Rating Tasty food but quite expensive. Big servings, hard to finish. Good coffee. Stuff is very welcoming. Clean tables.

Igor Semchenkov Pastukhov - 2 months ago

5 Star Rating This is my neighborhood IHOP, and the food is fresh and delicious. Service is good, too!! Definitely sign up for the email list so you can get a free stack of pancakes during your birth month. I ate pancakes for two days because they gave me so many!

Charise Lawrence - 3 months ago

The Red Doors    Overall Rating 3.9 out of 5The Red Doors Star Rating

The Red Doors restaurant
Photo Credit: Dimitrios Beis
The Red Doors map

Open Now

Hours This Week:
  • Monday: 1:00 PM – 12:00 AM
  • Tuesday: 1:00 PM – 12:00 AM
  • Wednesday: 1:00 PM – 12:00 AM
  • Thursday: 1:00 PM – 2:00 AM
  • Friday: 12:00 PM – 4:00 AM
  • Saturday: 12:00 PM – 4:00 AM
  • Sunday: 12:00 PM – 1:00 AM

Address: 1205 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224, USA

Phone: (718) 872-7177

Reviews

5 Star Rating I put 5 stars only because of one bartender in particular. His name is Tekhon and he works Sunday and Monday. He's very nice and tries to make a good time happen even if there's not a big crowd.

RaMPaGe ZoMBie - 1 month ago

3 Star Rating This is definitely a better option than the boardwalk but it could be better. Drinks were just ok and food was not fantastic but adequate. Would i visit again? Probably not but I don't regret stopping in for a quick bite and a drink. Service was fast. Bathrooms should be about cleaner.

Disc Mogul - 6 months ago

5 Star Rating Great night celebrating my friend's club's closing event. Great Bar staff, performance space, streetfront seating area, clean bathrooms and good drinks! Had a blast!

Larry Amanuel - 4 months ago

New York City Culinary Tours

Tour depiction

Italians of Greenwich Village Food Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $80.92 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

This is a fun-filled interactive walking tour of Greenwich Village's Italian neighborhood. See St. Anthony's Church, Raffetto's Pasta Store and then stroll Washington Square Park. Stroll past MacDougal Street's Caffe Reggio. This 2-hour tour is led by a local, licensed NYC tour guide with Italian family roots in the neighborhood for over 125 years. Your food tour guide gives you an insider's perspective into local history with music, serenades and family tales.   Samples subject to change.

Book Now

Tour depiction

New York City Meatball Tasting Tour

Rating 4 Star Rating

From: $80.92 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

This meatball crawl is a fun and yummy meatball tasting tour. Enjoy three tasty, savory, mouth watering meatballs - Venetian, Sicilian, Neopolitan followed by a creamy fruita-mi-su.

Book Now

Tour depiction

New York City Dessert Walk

Rating 4 Star Rating

From: $80.92 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Take a sugary stroll through NYC's famous and funky Greenwich Village - a sweet-tooth lover's dream!

Book Now

Tour depiction

Hell's Kitchen Dessert Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $80.23 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Discover some of the best sweets in one of New York City's busiest neighborhoods, Hell's Kitchen. Learn about this neighborhood's rough and tumble past as well as the city's culinary history while trying some of the best sweets that the Big Apple has to offer. From artisan handcrafted chocolates, traditional American pies, the best cookie in NYC, and more, you'll leave with a full stomach and new-found knowledge of NYC.

Book Now

Tour depiction

Chelsea and West Village Dessert Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $79.96 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Slow down your weekend afternoon with a sweeter than sugar dessert tour. You'll learn about the city’s culinary past, all while trying some of the greatest desserts the area has to offer. Mosey through the quaint Chelsea neighborhood, into Chelsea Market, down the High Line, and into the Meatpacking District. End your culinary adventure in the West Village.

Book Now

Tour depiction

Broadway Dessert Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $79.96 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

This walking dessert tour combines Broadway history with quintessentially New York-style desserts, led by a real NYC actor. Discover the stories behind the bright lights of Broadway and learn the history of the theater district as you try classic New York desserts like cheesecake, black and white cookies, and more. You’ll be a Great White Way expert before you leave!

Book Now


Visiting New York City? Here's why we use Booking.com for our hotel bookings.

Best SelectionDaily Deals Price Matching Pay at the Hotel 24/7 Support

Get a New York City Explorer Pass - the most flexible NYC attraction pass available

No rushing. Valid for a full 30 days after you visit your first attraction.
Convenient. One pass for multiple attractions.
Flexible. Available for 3, 4, 5, 7, or 10 attractions. Choose from 78 top attractions as you go.
Even More Flexible. Build your own custom pass.


Visiting New York City?
Here's why we use Booking.com for our hotel bookings.
Best Selection
Daily Deals
Price Matching
Pay at the Hotel
24/7 Support
Help us grow! Please Share
Thanks for Visiting!