Best NYC restaurants located within a 5 minute walk of Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Station | Ratings, Reviews & Maps

The following New York City restaurants are all conveniently located within a 5 minute walk of the Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Subway Station. They are sorted according to their overall rating on Yelp. When you are looking for a great place to eat near Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Station in NYC, any of the following restaurants should prove to be a good choice.

Totonno's

Yelp Rating:
4 out of 5 4 Star Rating
Based on 755 Reviews.

Totonno's
Totonno's map

Price: $$

Category: Pizza

Address:
1524 Neptune Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 372-8606

4 Star Rating I was here about 25 years ago. Think it was time for a trip back especially after watching "somebody feed Phil" and Ugly Delicious on Netflix. Both shows... Read More

Dona F. May-18-2019

3 Star Rating 3.5 Solid pizza. Nothing to hate about, but nothing to rave about imo. Knowing the history of the joint, wish it left more of an impression on me. Maybe... Read More

Sung K. Apr-30-2019

3 Star Rating Half & Half: Pros: - good sauce. - right out the oven and into the box. - Margherita half was better than topping half. Cons: - Had to wait an hour for... Read More

Judy C. Mar-31-2019

ChowTime

Yelp Rating:
4.5 out of 5 4.5 Star Rating
Based on 49 Reviews.

ChowTime
ChowTime map

Price: $

Category: Vietnamese Bubble Tea Chinese

Address:
1418 Mermaid Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (347) 713-1560

5 Star Rating I don't Yelp a lot but this place deserves it. I grew up in the San Francisco Bay Area where great Chinese food is plentiful. Moving to NYC was a huge... Read More

Arthur W. Apr-26-2019

4 Star Rating M.Y. and I stopped in here after a long bike ride down the shore parkway to Coney island. While most of the eateries in the area are concentrated on... Read More

Caroline L. May-14-2019

4 Star Rating I am amazed by the quality and quantity of this food. Very flavorful and not greasy or oily AT ALL. Not your average Chinese spot. They also have Vietnamese... Read More

Sergio P. Nov-20-2018

Doña Zita Mexican Restaurant

Yelp Rating:
4 out of 5 4 Star Rating
Based on 61 Reviews.

Doña Zita Mexican Restaurant
Doña Zita Mexican Restaurant map

Price: $

Category: Mexican

Address:
1221 Bowery St
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (347) 492-6160

5 Star Rating Best tacos ever!!!! I go so much they know my face already... I tell every one about this spot and I always let every one know on my fb when they open Read More

Laura H. Apr-20-2019

5 Star Rating The best Mexican food I've found in the NYC area!!! This Texan was so excited for a feast of tacos, tostadas, and even a cemita. A Jamaica agua fresca too,... Read More

Jennifer D. Sep-10-2018

5 Star Rating Wow did not expect to find this hidden gem in Coney Island! Reasonable price for Coney Island and amazing portion! Ordered the spicy meat taco and the... Read More

Michelle T. Aug-02-2018

Nathan's Famous

Yelp Rating:
3.5 out of 5 3.5 Star Rating
Based on 1120 Reviews.

Nathan's Famous
Nathan's Famous map

Price: $

Category: Hot Dogs Fast Food

Address:
1310 Surf Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 946-2202

4 Star Rating Hot dogs! The original is the best, I enjoyed the kraut. The French fries were hot and ketchup was free and plentiful. Everything is a bit grimy, but tasty.... Read More

Jamey B. Apr-20-2019

2 Star Rating Ugh I had the worst experience here today. They only had half of the lines open but I managed to find a short one with only 4 people in front of me. It... Read More

Jeff G. Apr-06-2019

5 Star Rating I love, love, love Nathan's chili cheese fries and original hotdogs with sauerkraut. And I typically dont like hotdogs. (Just Nathan's or Hebrew National).... Read More

Diana C. Mar-24-2019

Gargiulo's

Yelp Rating:
3.5 out of 5 3.5 Star Rating
Based on 215 Reviews.

Gargiulo's
Gargiulo's map

Price: $$

Category: Italian Venues & Event Spaces Seafood

Address:
2911 W 15th St
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 266-4891

4 Star Rating As a Brooklynite I am ashamed that I haven't been to this place before. It's an old school Brooklyn establishment that has been around for years. They... Read More

Donna P. May-03-2019

3 Star Rating Meh, pass. Three stars for cleanliness and great service, two stars for food. This was disappointing considering walking out with a $200+bill. My kid wanted... Read More

Krist D. Mar-29-2019

1 Star Rating Not sure why they received so many stars as I don't find this place all that great. Strict dress code - no white t-shirts, shorts, and flip flops. They will... Read More

Diana T. Jul-27-2018

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Yelp Rating:
3 out of 5 3 Star Rating
Based on 259 Reviews.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria
Grimaldi's Pizzeria map

Price: $$

Category: Pizza

Address:
1215 Surf Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 676-2630

4 Star Rating LOVE this place!!! If you're at Coney Island, definitely check out Grimaldi's. When you eat the pepperoni slices, straight out of the oven, it's... Read More

Jessica E. Apr-20-2019

5 Star Rating I love this place have been coming here for over 6 years. The more I came the more they treat me like a friend of the place. They celebrate my birthday and... Read More

Alma P. Mar-29-2019

2 Star Rating Not very good. Pizza quality is basic. Not tasty. Service was slow. Bathroom was very dirty. Won't go back. Read More

Chloe M. Mar-24-2019

Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest

Yelp Rating:
4 out of 5 4 Star Rating
Based on 25 Reviews.

Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest
Nathan's Hot Dog Eating Contest map

Category: Hot Dogs

Address:
1310 Surf Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 946-2202

5 Star Rating Nathan's Famous July 4th contest is really what NEW YORK is all about and makes America Great again again & gain. So I jumped on the "N" train from mid town... Read More

Frank B. Jul-04-2017

4 Star Rating I never knew there was an event page for the contest, until my return for some Coney Island randomness. So here's how my 1st contest day went for 2017. I... Read More

Farrah B. Aug-20-2017

4 Star Rating So, I went to the annual Nathan's Hotdog Eating Contest the year of their 100th anniversary in 2016 and surprisingly I wasn't one of the vegan protesters... Read More

Sari Marissa G. Jul-06-2016

Pizza On the Run

Yelp Rating:
4 out of 5 4 Star Rating
Based on 24 Reviews.

Pizza On the Run
Pizza On the Run map

Price: $

Category: Pizza

Address:
2932 Stillwell Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 946-6677

4 Star Rating This is one of those small local eat here or take out holes in the wall which are increasingly more difficult to find around the city other than the... Read More

Neil B. May-05-2014

3 Star Rating I have went into this pizza shop today, waiting for a family member get off the subway directly across the street. They had really good pizza, just had no... Read More

William B. Mar-08-2019

5 Star Rating An unheralded gem. Stay with family nearby on a once a year visit and hit this place a few times. The hot subs are huge and wonderful. The pizza of course... Read More

Lee B. Oct-07-2017

Walburgers

Yelp Rating:
2.5 out of 5 2.5 Star Rating
Based on 680 Reviews.

Walburgers
Walburgers map

Price: $$

Category: Burgers American (Traditional)

Address:
3015 Stillwell Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 942-4450

3 Star Rating I love the Wahlbergs, and wanted to love Wahlburgers. We tried it tonight.We didn't expect to find parking in Coney island of course.So I ordered and... Read More

Barbra B. Aug-26-2018

2 Star Rating One word. Understaffed. One person at the register. One person making milkshakes with one machine. Two people in the back kitchen. We were going to order... Read More

Yanni C. Aug-29-2018

2 Star Rating Disappointing. Lacked flavor and creativity. For once, I didn't check Yelp before trying a place out. What a mistake. Hubs said his burger had zero... Read More

Krystal W. Jun-28-2018

Footprints Cafe

Yelp Rating:
2.5 out of 5 2.5 Star Rating
Based on 342 Reviews.

Footprints Cafe
Footprints Cafe map

Price: $$

Category: Bars Caribbean Themed Cafes

Address:
1521 Surf Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224

Phone: (718) 265-2530

4 Star Rating Food was delicious! Service was great. Only downside was there bar selection was limited on the day I visited so my drink selections were unavailable. Other... Read More

Jessica A. Apr-17-2019

2 Star Rating Coney Island does have some delicious food choices; however, very little to no high quality sit down restaurants, so when I went out to lunch with some... Read More

Jordan B. Feb-10-2019

1 Star Rating If I could give this place NO stars as would. Besides the delivery was over an hour and a half wait.. then, we were missing an item. When spoken to the... Read More

Doris M. Dec-29-2018

New York City Culinary Tours

Tour depiction

Italians of Greenwich Village Food Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $80.49 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

This is a fun-filled interactive walking tour of Greenwich Village's Italian neighborhood. See St. Anthony's Church, Raffetto's Pasta Store and then stroll Washington Square Park. Stroll past MacDougal Street's Caffe Reggio. This 2-hour tour is led by a local, licensed NYC tour guide with Italian family roots in the neighborhood for over 125 years. Your food tour guide gives you an insider's perspective into local history with music, serenades and family tales.   Samples subject to change.

Book Now

Tour depiction

New York City Meatball Tasting Tour

Rating 4 Star Rating

From: $80.49 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

This meatball crawl is a fun and yummy meatball tasting tour. Enjoy three tasty, savory, mouth watering meatballs - Venetian, Sicilian, Neopolitan followed by a creamy fruita-mi-su.

Book Now

Tour depiction

New York City Dessert Walk

Rating 4 Star Rating

From: $80.49 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Take a sugary stroll through NYC's famous and funky Greenwich Village - a sweet-tooth lover's dream!

Book Now

Tour depiction

Hell's Kitchen Dessert Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $79.81 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Discover some of the best sweets in one of New York City's busiest neighborhoods, Hell's Kitchen. Learn about this neighborhood's rough and tumble past as well as the city's culinary history while trying some of the best sweets that the Big Apple has to offer. From artisan handcrafted chocolates, traditional American pies, the best cookie in NYC, and more, you'll leave with a full stomach and new-found knowledge of NYC.

Book Now

Tour depiction

Chelsea and West Village Dessert Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $79.53 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

Slow down your weekend afternoon with a sweeter than sugar dessert tour. You'll learn about the city’s culinary past, all while trying some of the greatest desserts the area has to offer. Mosey through the quaint Chelsea neighborhood, into Chelsea Market, down the High Line, and into the Meatpacking District. End your culinary adventure in the West Village.

Book Now

Tour depiction

Broadway Dessert Tour

Rating 5 Star Rating

From: $79.53 CAD...May vary slightly due to currency fluctuations

This walking dessert tour combines Broadway history with quintessentially New York-style desserts, led by a real NYC actor. Discover the stories behind the bright lights of Broadway and learn the history of the theater district as you try classic New York desserts like cheesecake, black and white cookies, and more. You’ll be a Great White Way expert before you leave!

Book Now


Visiting New York City? Here's why we use Booking.com for our hotel bookings.

Best SelectionDaily Deals Price Matching Pay at the Hotel 24/7 Support

Get a New York City Explorer Pass - the most flexible NYC attraction pass available

No rushing. Valid for a full 30 days after you visit your first attraction.
Convenient. One pass for multiple attractions.
Flexible. Available for 3, 4, 5, 7, or 10 attractions. Choose from 78 top attractions as you go.
Even More Flexible. Build your own custom pass.


Visiting New York City?
Here's why we use Booking.com for our hotel bookings.
Best Selection
Daily Deals
Price Matching
Pay at the Hotel
24/7 Support
Help us grow! Please Share
Thanks for Visiting!