NYC restaurants located within a 5 minute walk of Coney Island – Stillwell Avenue Station | Ratings, Reviews & Maps

The first place we went after getting off the subway on our day trip to Coney Island was to the original Nathan's Famous restaurant on the corner of Stilwell St & Surf St, about 200 yards from the subway station. We had read about this famous restaurant, which began in 1916 as a nickel hot dog stand in Coney Island operated by Nathan Handwerker a Jewish-Polish  immigrant, and wanted to try their famous hot dogs. There's a seafood section on the left hand side as you enter the long Surf St store front and a hot dog section on the right. I ordered the original hotdog with sautéed onions & a large pint of draft Brooklyn beer for my wife and a chilli dog with sautéed onions & extra jalapeños with 1/2 pint of the draft Coney Island Mermaid IPA beer for myself, at one of the self order kiosks. The kiosks only accepted credit card payments and I'm not sure if you could pay with cash. I choose the eating in option, paid $40 and waited for a server to call out my name to pick up my order from the counter. It wasn't busy on our visit so our food & drinks came out pretty quickly. Ketchup, mustard, napkins & plastic cutlery were provided on self service carts by the entrances to the store. After loading up on mustard & Ketchup on our hot dogs, we found a table in the large outdoor seating area, which had restrooms at the far end of it. The hot dogs were very tasty on fluffy, soft lightly toasted rolls & I particularly enjoyed the extra bit of heat & crunch provided by the fresh jalapeños on my hot dog. My wife's Brooklyn beer was a dark hoppy beer & my Coney Island Mermaid IPA beer was lighter & fruity. Both beers were refreshingly cold and perfectly accompanied our hot dogs. The hot dogs are fairly small so I went back to the counter and ordered 4 delicious chicken tender pieces (which were perfectly crunchy on the outside, tender & moist inside) accompanied by a fantastic honey mustard sauce, together with another Nathan's original hotdog to share, for $15. We really enjoyed our first experience of Nathan's Famous food and beers sitting outdoors in the hot late summer sun, near the sea👍 We passed another Nathan's store when we walked along the Boardwalk and just managed to resist our urges to have another of their delicious hotdogs 🤣
Hong Lee - 2 months ago

Had to visit the original location of my favorite chilli dogs! Love those classic fries as well. Great snap to the dogs and the famous chilli recipe did not disappoint. Fries were on point as well. Very quiet because I went during the off-season, but it was a Birthday treat and did not disappoint! 😁
Bill Peterson - 2 months ago

I stopped by Nathan’s Famous in Coney Island since it’s such a well-known spot. The place has that classic boardwalk vibe, and it was fun to finally try their original hot dog. Honestly though, the hot dog itself was just okay—nothing particularly special to me. It was nice for the experience and the history behind it, but taste-wise, it didn’t really stand out, yet was quite pricy.
Joan L - a month ago

I grew up in Coney Island eating red clam chowder and hot dogs. The hot dogs, fries, shrimp were great but the clam chowder was not as good as I remember. I liked the fact we could eat inside and very clean bathrooms.
Lourdes Rivera - a week ago

The hot dogs were good but they didn't taste all that different from their store bought Nathan's hot dogs and the cookie was okay but not that good. The hot dog wasn't worth the price in my opinion but it was a nice Novelty. And they do have pretty good mustard and normal ketchup at the place with outdoor seating next to the amusement park.
Ben - 5 months ago

Read all Reviews

Woooow such an amazing experience! Stepping into this restaurant was like going back in time 60 years to a bygone era of the godfather and goodfellas. Tuxedo clad waiters and a dress code with classy 1960s era of fine dining was such a cool experience. Our waiter Jerry was soooo classy, funny, and friendly! He was able to explain everything in the menu with detail and gave us awesome recommendations. The food was spectacular 60s era Italian dining with baked clams, veal Parmesan, and an absolutely massive seafood pasta platter that they served on still in the pan. Absolutely spectacular gargiulo’s is a must visit when you come to Coney Island, grazie mille!
Ray Wu Adventures - 5 months ago

We had just arrived in town and needed a nice meal. Wow, did we hit the jackpot! Greeted at the door by the owner, atmosphere was gorgeous yet comfortable, food was amazing, Emilio, our server, was not only professional, but friendly, and made our dining experience that much more special. Very reasonably priced for this quality of food and level of service. On the way out we spoke to George, the bartender, I can’t wait to come back and try one of his espresso martinis! Thank you!
Diane Stevers - 8 months ago

Held 60th Birthday, 10th Anniversary combined celebration. Had a great time. Service was outstanding and atmosphere perfect. Anthony and his team are to be commended. Reasonably priced also. Thanks again.
Rev Dr. Leon Daryl Williams, Jr - 4 months ago

It's been way too long since my last visit to Gargiulo's. It was even better than I had remembered. We'll worth the trip, you won't be disappointed.
Douglas Considine - a week ago

The food here is absolutely divine, and the atmosphere is simply electrifying! The live music adds a whole new level of excitement. It's impossible to resist the urge to jump up and dance! We decided to celebrate Valentine's Day here, and let me tell you, it was an exceptional experience. I cannot recommend this place enough.
Jean Farrell - a year ago

Read all Reviews

Totonno’s in Coney Island is a true NYC classic. The pizza is excellent — you can really taste the quality ingredients and the care that goes into making it. The staff are wonderful, straight-up authentic New Yorkers, which makes the whole experience even better. The old-school atmosphere feels like stepping back in time, and you can sense the history in every corner. This place is a real gem and such an important part of New York’s pizza story. Definitely worth the trip.
John Gonsalves - 3 months ago

Visited Totonno’s Pizza today. Located in Coney Island, this institution is only open on Saturday and Sunday from 12 to 5 PM. There is a lot to love about this pizza.   The crust was baked just right. Each bite you heard a satisfying crunch unlike other pizzas that are doughy. The end/crust was puffy and not flat. Lastly, the sauce, mozzarella, and Parmesan cheese round out your sensory overload! Coal fired pizzas take on a different flavor vs. wood and gas stoves. If you are in the area, you must try one of the few remaining coal fired pizza restaurants in New York City. Recent regulations have made it extremely costly for these restaurants to remain in business.  They only sell one size starting at $27 for a margarita. Visit them and check out Coney Island along the way.
jonathan geiger - 2 months ago

Totonno’s is a classic. It used to be better back in the early 90s, but maybe my taste buds have changed. The last time I ate there was just before Covid. I think the sauce used to have a bit more zing or something, I recall it lost its luster. I read in a NY Times article that this place is now for sale. That’s probably for the best. Keep the coal oven running if it’s grandfathered in. It would be a shame to extinguish it. I’ve always eaten here when it had indoor dining, so that’s why I gave it 4 ⭐️. That being said, I wouldn’t take the train out now just to be told I had to sit on a curb to eat my pizza. (That’s for rubes or pizza nerds, of which I am neither.)
Bob - 3 months ago

You have to go inside and order your whole pie, pay and provide your phone number. They will call you when the pie is ready for pickup. No eating inside so you can take your pie out and eat on the curb, like we did … I have to say that one pie is great for 2 people and the dough is exceptional.
Alexandra Gorelik - 6 months ago

Incredible! Real New York pizza in fact the best! Totonno's has been in Coney Island for 100 years! This establishment is a landmark and beautiful historical part of Brooklyn. You have to order in advance and no inside dinning but trust me you will never forget why NYC has the best pizza in America after you have had Totonno's!
Pink Velvet Witch - 6 months ago

Read all Reviews

Great time was had by all. Exception being there was no food to purchase and I was very disappointed. My first time to this venue and the only problem was food service stops too early in my opinion and I'd you book a party, please expect people will want to eat. 4 stars due to lack of food. Will definitely return...
Shelly Stafford - 2 months ago

Had my first date here and the customer service was amazing. The burgers were delicious but what makes me and my man come back, is the mozzarella sticks. They are the best mozzarella sticks we ever had. The ambiance is chill which we love. Will be coming back soon for our anniversary ❤️
Jasmine Alexander - 2 months ago

Drinks are reasonable but the service was non existent. Not sure which waitress it was but one had an attitude as if I owed her something. Over all experience on show was great, food good but you might want to get people who wants to work and kind to your customers.
Roberto Gonzalez - a month ago

This is a prime location. Upon entering the restaurant, it has a nice vibe. The music is cool. As far as service, that was good. The drinks were so yummy. I had the Tiramisu Martini. That was delicious! The food wasn't quality. The Caesar Salad was okay. The chicken was dry and bland. The Jalapeño Poppers were average. The only nice touch was the aged cheese. Will I come here again? Only for a drink.
Alice Rodrigo - a year ago

Read all Reviews

This has to be the worst Popeyes experience I have ever had. There was vomit on the seats in the restaurant, a customer was openly vaping at a booth while they waited for their food, the wait was insane and the food itself was a disaster. The red beans and rice was not fully cooked, the sauce content on the chicken was laughable and the "wings" were not even wings as there was no bone in the chicken which I asked for. Also, I am quite sure that there was only one guy working both stations (register and food). If that is the case then I don't blame him, there is only so much one guy can do. But honestly that is the manager's fault for not hiring enough staff. The overall experience was not worth the $25 that I paid for the order. I normally have a decent experience at this place so I am quite surprised that the quality has gone down so much. I hope this changes really soon. Otherwise, I am never coming back to this location.
Al -I Hate Google- XP - 5 months ago

I have ordered from here multiple times on the app. No matter how much earlier you order on the app, they never have your order ready when you get there. Gotta wait in line and they put together your mobile order. Might as well just go there and order. Makes no difference. Expect to spend a lot of time waiting to pick up your mobile order.
Allen Soohoo - a week ago

Read all Reviews

Good value for money, very friendly staff. Yara was really helpful and charming. A friendly diner like family restaurant. Just the meat on the big steak omelette was a bit chewy, the restrooms are not exceptionally clean, and some seats need a more professional repair.
Steven - 2 months ago

Came here for a Saturday morning breakfast and it was fantastic all across the board. I had the ‘Have it ALL’ breakfast and it really did have it ALL. I did add a couple of extra sausage links but it was not necessary. Everything was delicious and the atmosphere was perfect. The super awesome icing on the cake was our server Yara. She was super professional, attentive, courteous, and friendly. We had a lovely chat and it rounded out our experience to perfect. We are looking forward to our next visit soon. Thank You ✌️❤️
Vadim Stern - a month ago

This is hands down the best IHOP I have ever eaten at. The place was clean , the service was on point and the food was delicious . Not greasy at all . This will be my new breakfast spot in Brooklyn
Tim utterback - 2 months ago

The service was great but the food was a bit off, my hashbrowns tasted weird and the biscuit was undercooked
satu - 2 months ago

This was my best experience with IHOP so far. I always have the same few things that I've tried and love: the hot chocolate, the chocolate milkshake, and the 2x2x2 combo (2 buttermilk pancakes, 2 eggs any style, and 2 bacon strips or sausages). We also ordered a side of fresh strawberries. Although that is not my usual experience, this time, the service was very fast (they are always nice, though! Just it usually takes some time to get a server to notice you). The bathrooms were spacious and clean. I love the food. The pictures show the 2 combos and a strawberry & banana French Toast, but the friend who ordered it wasn't too happy with it.
Fernanda Albuquerque de Araujo - a year ago

Read all Reviews

Stopped by early for a couple of drinks. Plenty of seating, service was good. Walked around for a while then decided to go back for more. Small crowd had filled up most of the place and still got good service. Bartenders were busy but still made time to follow up on our drink orders to make sure she got them right. Will be back.
vic carr - a month ago

Went there today while in Coney Island and so happy we found this gem. Kennedy and Scott was amazing. We definitely need will be back. If you want good drinks and good vibes this is a great spot …
Ruby Martinez - 3 months ago

This is my go to place! It has amazing service with great prices! It is very comfortable and cozy place to spend you time with friends! If you’re looking for place with good music and something live music you must come here! I am highly recommend to every one !
Anna Vysochina - 5 months ago

Great experience stumbling upon Margarita Island on a rainy Saturday night. While the rest of Coney was closed, Scott and the crew at Margarita Island welcomed us in with open arms (and pitchers of beer.) While we all hung in the front bar area, they have a large backyard that looked like another fun spot to hang. Big recommend if you’re on Coney!
Ian Blau - 5 months ago

Read all Reviews

Amazing pizza and service. Our whole family enjoyed the pizza here. We tried the meat lovers and the pepperoni. This is a family ran restaurant and they had a great atmosphere. There was a lot of seating for large groups and the service was very fast.
Andrew Chalmers - 4 weeks ago

I went to Surf City Pizzeria with a couple of friends, and we had such a lovely time! It’s a cozy and pleasant spot with a really welcoming atmosphere. The place was pretty clean, and the staff were super friendly and attentive. We ordered three wraps, and they were absolutely delicious — plus the portions were huge for only $14, which is such a great deal! The pizza at the table next to us looked amazing, so I’m definitely planning to try it next time. It’s the perfect spot to visit in the summer, but honestly, it’s a great place to hang out any time of year. I’d definitely come back!
Anna Toptalina - 7 months ago

Mussels and baked clams were ridiculous. Delicious. Oh and the grandma slice is one of the best in the city
Max Furman - a week ago

Some of the best food I’ve ever had. The pizza was hot, fresh, and checked off all the boxes for what I love in a pizza. Service was good
Tori MacKeil - 3 months ago

Very impressed, food was amazing. recommend sitting by the Zoltar machine if you aren’t a fan of loud music.
Darin Morrison-beer - 3 months ago

Read all Reviews

Decent food for a decent price. Got the chicken and broccoli and cheese wantons. Only thing is that there’s a $15 minimum. So I had to order extra food just to meet it. Who has cash? Anyway, I’d order again. Delicious on a cold, winter day.
Silvio The Wolf - 6 months ago

They have Vegetarian options. I always order the Vegetable Dumplings with Vegetable Lo mein and the food is tasty. Service is good
Maxi - a month ago

Read all Reviews

The best pizza in Coney Island. The grandma slice is to die for, and their regular slice (cheese slice) tastes like old Mew Yrok Pizza. Get it extra hot!! You won't regret it!
Cinenyi Fanini-Rodriguez - 5 months ago

Good slice with a good fold and a nice, crispy, crust. The slice was heavier on the cheese than anything else which may be preferable to some, but not to those looking for a more balanced slice. Friendly staff and quick service.
Wet Sofa - a year ago

I consider myself a pretty big fan of pizza. I've been to many pizza places in my life. Between my husband and I, this is our top favorite pizza of anywhere in the world. Keep it simple with cheese or pepperoni. And add an extra slice because you'll definitely want more.
Kathryn Pham - 5 months ago

Tried Pizza on the Run and was pleasantly surprised! The pizza was absolutely delicious and ready in just 15 minutes. The place shows a bit of wear and tear, but the staff were very friendly and welcoming. Prices are a little on the higher side, likely due to the location near Coney Island and the beach—but overall, a solid spot for a quick and tasty bite.
Levani S - 5 months ago

Read all Reviews